Fantasy Analysis: Rohit Sharma vs. Virat Kohli – Who to Pick for Your Dream11 Team?

The dilemma of choosing between Rohit Sharma and Virat Kohli continues to challenge fantasy cricket players, especially when both icons are available in the same contest. These two veterans of Indian cricket, now focusing largely on IPL and ODI formats, remain reliable picks in the world of fantasy cricket. 

Yet, when only one can be your captain or vice-captain, the decision becomes critical. Should you bank on Rohit’s explosiveness or Kohli’s unmatched consistency? 

This blog presents a detailed analysis grounded in recent data and match performance trends. From current form and key fantasy stats to situational matchups, here’s everything you need to know before locking in your best team for Dream11 today match.

Current Form Analysis (Last 3–6 Months)

Rohit Sharma's Recent Performance

Rohit Sharma’s IPL 2025 campaign was a blend of aggression and milestone moments. Playing for Mumbai Indians, he featured in 15 matches, scoring 418 runs at an average of 29.86 and an impressive strike rate of 149.29. 

His standout knock was an unbeaten 81 runs against GT in the Eliminator, his highest individual score in IPL 2025, reflecting his ability to score rapidly when settled. However, in the 2nd Qualifier, the Indian striker was dismissed after scoring 8 runs off 7 deliveries, which raises concerns about his performance in a high-pressure match. 

Another impactful performance of Rohit Sharma came against the CSK, where he anchored the innings with a brisk 76* off 45 balls. In this IPL season, Rohit also became the second player to score over 7,000 IPL runs, joining Virat Kohli in the elite club. Additionally, he smashed his 300th IPL six in the same season, reinforcing his legacy as one of the most dominant openers in the tournament’s history.

From a fitness and availability standpoint, Rohit has managed his schedule smartly. No significant injuries have been reported in 2025, and his absence from T20Is has allowed him to maintain his energy levels for the IPL and bilateral ODIs. While his form has been slightly patchy in ODIs, he still contributes important starts, especially when playing on Indian pitches.

Virat Kohli's Recent Performance

Virat Kohli had one of his finest IPL seasons in recent memory in 2025. Representing Royal Challengers Bengaluru, he scored 657 runs in 15 innings at an outstanding average of 54.75 and a strike rate of 144.71. He notched up 8 half-centuries, showing remarkable consistency across venues and conditions.

Kohli’s form peaked at the right time during the playoffs. In the IPL final, he scored 43 runs off 35 balls, anchoring the chase and guiding RCB to their maiden IPL title. He overtook Shikhar Dhawan and set the record for the most number of fours in IPL in the same match. Along with that, Kohli has also broken the record of David Warner for having the most number of 50+ scores in IPL history this season, with 67 half-centuries. 

He also recorded an unbeaten 73 in a key league match. He is known for his ability to remain calm and finish games under pressure, especially in the second innings. His performances against top-tier teams, such as CSK, LSG, and MI, were particularly noteworthy.

In the ODI format, Kohli’s performance remained steady. Across his last 10 matches, he registered five 50+ scores, including two centuries. His ability to play long innings and rotate strike makes him a reliable fantasy selection. 

Now that he’s retired from T20Is and Tests, his full focus is on ODIs this year.

Key Fantasy Stats Comparison

Rohit Sharma

• Average fantasy points: ~ 63

• Best 11%: 39

• Top SCore%: 12

• Last 5 matches avg: 49

Rohit is a fantasy pick best utilised in contests where early dominance is rewarded. He is highly effective when batting first on flat wickets, particularly at venues like Wankhede and Chinnaswamy, where boundaries flow easily in the powerplay.

Virat Kohli

• Average fantasy points: ~ 76

• Best 11%: 61

• Top SCore%: 15

• Last 5 matches avg: 84

Kohli’s strength lies in his ability to anchor the innings and accumulate runs efficiently. He rarely throws his wicket away and has one of the best dot-ball to run conversion ratios in the league. Even when not scoring big, he consistently delivers 30 - 40 fantasy points through strike rotation, singles, doubles, and boundaries spread across the innings.

Who to Pick in Your Dream11 Team

When to Pick Rohit Sharma

Rohit is the ideal pick in scenarios where:

• The pitch is flat and batting-friendly: He’s particularly effective on high-scoring tracks like Wankhede in Mumbai, Rajiv Gandhi Stadium in Hyderabad, and Chinnaswamy in Bengaluru.

• The team is batting first: Rohit’s aggressive starts in the powerplay can generate massive fantasy returns early.

• You’re playing a Grand League: His ability to convert starts into explosive 70+ scores makes him a high-reward option.

When to Pick Virat Kohli

Kohli is the best pick when:

• If he is batting second: Kohli has a reputation for stepping up in the second innings, especially during a big run chase.

• Batting conditions are slightly challenging: On slow or spinning wickets, he adapts better than most top-order batters.

• The game demands anchoring: Kohli’s role as a middle-overs stabiliser often yields consistent fantasy scores.

• You need safe captaincy points: Virat Kohli's record in ICC knockout matches shows that he has a strike rate of  145.13 in T20 format. In Small Leagues or highly competitive head-to-head matches, he provides reliability with fewer low scores.

The Verdict: Who to Pick?

Both players offer immense value, but their suitability depends heavily on match dynamics and contest format.

• For Small Leagues: Virat Kohli should be your preferred pick due to his consistent scoring and anchor role. His floor is higher, and he’s less likely to fail.

• For Grand Leagues: Rohit Sharma’s explosiveness makes him a better differential. His higher strike rate and boundary frequency make him more rewarding in the right conditions.

• When to pick both: If you expect a high-scoring game or flat pitch, and both players are in form, selecting both in your XI (with one as VC) can optimise your total points.

Ultimately, Kohli offers a stable points return almost every time he walks out to bat, while Rohit provides the possibility of a 3x return on days when he is in form.

How 11Wizards Helps You Pick the Right Choice

The 11Wizards platform makes such choices easier with real-time data insights:

• Historical data overlays: Compare how Kohli and Rohit have performed against the same opposition in similar venues.

• Form-based projections: View their performances across the last 5 matches.

• Venue and condition-based recommendations: Suggestions vary based on the pitch's nature, the toss result, and the match context.

• Custom team-building: Lock either Kohli or Rohit in your team and let the algorithm build around your preference, taking budget and contest type into account.

• Post-toss flexibility: Adjust your team in minutes with post-toss player status updates and batting order predictions.

• Cross-platform team exports: Whether you’re playing on Dream11, MyTeam11, My11Circle, Howzat, Vision11 or Cricbuzz11, export your optimised team with one tap.

Conclusion

Picking between Rohit Sharma and Virat Kohli doesn't have to be a coin toss. The smarter play lies in reading the pitch, reviewing player roles, and analysing current form. Kohli remains the go-to option for steady fantasy scoring, especially when consistency is vital. Rohit, however, brings unmatched explosiveness to the table, especially in Grand League scenarios.

Fantasy team Prediction Apps like 11Wizards help decode such fantasy matchups with data-led suggestions, situational filters, and flexible team-building logic. So, next time both legends feature in a contest, don’t guess but analyse. If the conditions favour both, build around both and maximise your return from two of India’s greatest modern-day batters.